Here you can find the best responses for each of the question on ‘A Temporary Matter’ which were posted around the room. They are in no particular order, but they will give you an indication of some of the ideas that the story explores, so read them carefully.
Questions from Year 11 Transition:
- In Shoba and Shukumar’s world the lights have gone out. Describe the reasons behind the darkness in their lives.
- What indications are there that neither Shoba nor Shukumar are coping effectively with their individual grief?
- As the darkness provides a shield for their emotions, how do Shoba and Shukumar’s revelations oscillate between intimacy and betrayal?
- The small candles seem to offer a flicker of hope, but what evidence is there that hope lingers in the marriage of Shoba and Shukumar?
- “They wept together for the things they now knew.” What is the significance of the story’s final line?
- Is the disconnection of Shoba and Shukumar likely to be “a temporary matter”? Explain your point of view by providing evidence from the text.
- Consider Shoba’s approach to life before the loss of her baby. How do these behaviours alter after the loss? Can you explain why she may now feel disillusioned with her ability to control her life and create security?
- Consider the title of this short story collection: ‘Interpreter of Madalies’. What is a malady? Can you identify the malady in this story? Why are interpreters needed? What problem is there with communication in this story?