Faith and Imagination

 

Part 1: Unity and Difference (Chapter 23)

A couple of years have passed since Pi’s last relation of events in his life and he’s been practicing his religions in triplicate for a couple of years, now 16. While at the beach, all three of the religious leaders Pi studies with appear and meet his family. He knows his choice of religious multiplicity will not be accepted and when the priest says Pi is a good Christian, the others react confusedly. They argue for a bit, declaring Pi as their own until they agree that it is okay for him to be so religious and a seeker of God. However, they end up deciding that he cannot be of all three religions and must choose one. His reply, “I just want to love God” quiets them all and they walk away. The family walks on with some ice cream and the matter is left alone.

  • Why is there a need for ‘competition’ among religion?
  • How do each of religious men see the others? Why is it that these men are focusing on the differences between their faiths while Pi is focused on the similarities?
  • Pi says “Bapu Gandhi said ‘All religions are true.’ I just want to love God.” Why are the religious men so bothered by Pi’s practice of all three faiths simultaneously?

 

 

Part 2: Different Perspectives, Same Vision (Chapter 31)

As Pi awaits Mr. Kumar (the Sufi) in his father’s zoo, he worries because he cannot recognize him, rubbing his eyes as an excuse for not seeing him arrive. When he does arrive, they take a walk and discuss the different animals and how they interact, especially the Zebras. The other Mr. Kumar arrives and Pi lets them both feed the Zebras with a carrot. They all marvel at the beauty of the experience. The two Kumars, representing science and religion interact the same with nature in this scene.

  • What is the significance of this chapter and what does it say about the views of science and religion?
  • If science explains what we know and religion explains what we do not (yet) know, might they be part of the same continuum of knowledge and understanding?

 

 

Part 3: The Better Story (Chapter 22)

Pi thinks on how an atheist might experience death, upon that final revelation. He once again brings up his unhappiness with agnosticism and how an agnostic in death might cling to “dry, yeastless factuality” and miss the “better story” as mentioned by the author in Chapter 21. He does not appreciate their lack of imagination and faith.

  • Chapter 22 holds a key statement in the novel – if we lack imagination (faith), we miss the better story. To what extent is this true?

 

orange divider 2

 

Pi and Religion

“…Hindus, in their capacity for love, are indeed hairless Christians, just as Muslims, in the way they see god in everything, are bearded Hindus, and Christians, in their devotion to God, are hat-wearing Muslims.” (p. 50)

 

Hinduism

Conduct some brief research into Hinduism:

  • Where is it practiced?
  • What are the core beliefs?
  • What are the core practices?

Read chapter 16 of Life of Pi and consider:

  • How does Pi come to be a Hindu?
  • What is it about Hinduism that appeals to Pi?
  • What is revealed about the nature of religion and its importance to Pi through this chapter?
  • How does this chapter illustrate Pi’s desire to “just…love God” (p.69)?

Create a poster that explains the importance of Hindu beliefs to Pi and its role within the novel. Your poster should provide answers to the above questions, and should include:

  • Several key quotes, at least four of which should have their significance explained.
  • At least two images which are connected with the ideas discussed in the novel. Each image should have a caption that explains what it is and why it has been chosen and how it links to the novel.
  • Any other insights into religion, spirituality, belief or Pi’s personality that emerge while your are undertaking this task.

 

Christianity

Conduct some brief research into Christianity:

  • Where is it practiced?
  • What are the core beliefs?
  • What are the core practices?

Read chapter 17 of Life of Pi and consider:

  • How does Pi come to be a Christian?
  • What is it about Christianity that appeals to Pi?
  • What is revealed about the nature of religion and its importance to Pi through this chapter?
  • How does this chapter illustrate Pi’s desire to “just…love God” (p.69)?

Create a poster that explains the importance of Christian beliefs to Pi and its role within the novel. Your poster should provide answers to the above questions, and should include:

  • Several key quotes, at least four of which should have their significance explained.
  • At least two images which are connected with the ideas discussed in the novel. Each image should have a caption that explains what it is and why it has been chosen and how it links to the novel.
  • Any other insights into religion, spirituality, belief or Pi’s personality that emerge while your are undertaking this task.

 

Islam

Conduct some brief research into Islam:

  • Where is it practiced?
  • What are the core beliefs?
  • What are the core practices?

Read chapters 18, 19 and 20 of Life of Pi and consider:

  • How does Pi come to be a Muslim?
  • What is it about Islam that appeals to Pi?
  • What is revealed about the nature of religion through these chapters?
  • What is revealed about the nature of religion and its importance to Pi through this chapter?
  • How does this chapter illustrate Pi’s desire to “just…love God” (p.69)?

 

Create a poster that explains the importance of Islamic beliefs to Pi and its role within the novel. Your poster should provide answers to the above questions, and should include:

  • Several key quotes, at least four of which should have their significance explained.
  • At least two images which are connected with the ideas discussed in the novel. Each image should have a caption that explains what it is and why it has been chosen.
  • Any other insights into religion, spirituality, belief or Pi’s personality that emerge while your are undertaking this task.

 

orange divider 2

 

Life of Pi: Chapters 1 to 10

 

Answer the following questions in full sentences in your exercise books. These answers will form your notes for the opening of the novel. Use quotes from the novel wherever appropriate in order to develop your answers further.

Make sure that you highlight and annotate any parts of the book that you think could be useful! Pay particular attention to any references to STORYTELLING, RELIGION or NATURE!

 

Chapter 1

The novel changes to Pi Patel’s voice now, told in the first person as a memoir. The narrator first introduces himself as a graduate in both Religious Studies and Zoology at the University of Toronto. He describes his thesis on the thyroid gland of a three-­‐toed sloth and goes on in detail about that sloth. He was given great credit for his knowledge in the zoology field but also held back because of his inability to divide religion and science. He describes the Goddess Lakshmi, a Hindu deity and how he misses India despite his love for Canada. He also describes how he misses Richard Parker. He goes on to mention his time in Mexico and a situation in an Indian restaurant in Canada.

  1. Why does Pi say he chose the three-­toed-­sloth as his subject of study? How might the sloth “soothe [his] shattered self”? (p 3)
  2. In what way does the three-­toed-­sloth remind Pi of God?
  3. Pi suggests that “[w]hen you’ve suffered a great deal in life, each additional pain is both unbearable and trifling.” (p 5) Explain what he means.
  4. Pi explains that Oxford “is fifth on the list of cities I would like to visit before I pass on, after Mecca, Varanasi, Jerusalem and Paris.” (p 6). Explain Pi’s choice of cities.
  5. Why do the waiter’s comments in the restaurant wound Pi?

 

Chapter 2

Returning to the Author’s narration, we learn that Pi Patel lives in Scarborough and is a small man of about forty. He speaks very fast and begins his story. This Chapter reminds the reader that Chapter one was the beginning of an interview, which will continue.

 

Chapter 3

Pi relates about Francis Adirubasamy, a friend of the Patel family. As a world champion swimmer, he always tried to teach the Patel family to swim, but only succeeded with Pi. We also learn that Francis was a great fan of the swimming pools of Paris, including one in particular, the Piscine Molitor, which his family subsequently named Pi after. It is only at this point that the reader is given Piscine Molitor Patel’s full name.

  1. Why was swimming Mamaji’s “gift” to Pi?
  2. What is it about Mamaji’s stories that captivate Pi’s father? Why might he have chosen to name his son after a swimming pool in Paris when Pondicherry has the expanse of the Indian Ocean at its feet?

 

Chapter 4

Pi describes the beautiful Pondicherry Zoo, run by his father, a former hotel operator. He compares the keeping of a zoo to the keeping of a hotel and how animals are similar to hotel occupants. While growing up in a zoo, Pi learns much of the world of nature. He loves the beauty and perfection of it all and sees the animals as happy for having their own territories. He claims that animals in the wild do not truly have freedom because they are dictated by their predators and the space restrictions.

  1. Pi questions the notion that animals are unhappy in zoos because their freedom is curtailed. Explain the reasons he gives.
  2. The Chapter ends with Pi comparing peoples’ problems with zoos with their problem with religion and suggests that “Certain illusions about freedom plague them both.” (p 19) What might he mean?

 

Chapter 5

Pi was unhappy as a child with his name (Piscine), as it was often mispronounced as “pissing” when it is meant to be pronounced as “pea-­‐seen” . For that reason as he grows up and enters the next level of school, he makes a show of jumping up during roll call and announcing to the class that his name is “Pi” even illustrating it with the mathematical symbol on the chalkboard.

  1. Why is it, as Pi suggests, “a law of human nature that those who live by the sea are suspicious of swimmers”? (p 22)
  2. Pi explains “in that elusive, irrational number with which scientists try to understand the universe, I found refuge.” (p 24) How does this explain Pi’s character and nature?

 

Chapter 6

The author interjects again, describing Patel’s cooking ability as an adult and his back stock of food, enough to “last the siege of Leningrad.”

 

Chapter 7

Pi meets with Satish Kumar, a very particular teacher of his – a communist, atheist, biology teacher, and one of Pi’s favourites. Satish Kumar begins to relay his belief that all things can be described scientifically, describing his bout with polio and how medicine saved him as a child, not God. Pi comments on how atheists are more acceptable than agnostics, who are full of doubt.

  1. Explain the reason Mr Kumar sees religion as darkness and Pi sees religion as light.
  2. Pi sees atheists and agnostics very differently. Why is this?

 

Chapter 8

Visitors to the zoo are responsible for performing a great deal of horrible things with the animals, declaring humans as the worst of all animals. Pi’s father shows the boys a tiger that has not been fed for three days, a standard condition in the wild. Watching what occurs when a goat is introduced to the cage scares “the living vegetarian daylights” out of Pi. His father goes on to describe the strength of every animal in the zoo against human beings; that is of course except guinea pigs.

  1. Why does Pi suggest that the most dangerous animal in a zoo is man and that even more dangerous is Animalus anthropomorphicus?
  2. Why might Pi have “anthropomorphized the animals until they spoke fluent English”? (p 34)

 

Chapter 9

Starting here, Pi describes some of the science of zoology and zoo keeping. Here he goes on about flight distance and how far an animal will stay from an enemy. That distance can be diminished by offering ample food, water, and shelter.

  1. What does Pi’s father’s “intuitive gift” say about the relationship between animals and humans?

 

Chapter 10

Pi describes animals that would not enjoy captivity, those that were captured and brought to the zoo or those few zoo bred creatures that temporarily feel the instinctual call to leave. He describes how animals are leaving something not seeking something when they escape.

 

 

KEY IDEAS: Storytelling, Religion, Nature

Building upon your answers to chapters 1 to 9, explain in detail how the following ideas are established and explored in this early part novel:

  • STORYTELLING: what makes good storytelling/what makes stories come to life/why are stories important to people?
  • RELIGION: what is the role of religion in peoples’ lives/what is the purpose of religion/how can religion give meaning to existence?
  • NATURE: what is the relationship between people and nature/what is the relationship between animals and nature/what is the relationship between humans and animals?

Be aware that these three key ideas will form much of the main focus of the novel. Keep them in mind as you continue to work through the novel, and consider what Pi’s tale reveals about each key concept.

 

 

Holiday Homework, Norm Fary and After Dinner Speeches

 

Holiday Homework:

Mandatory:

  • Complete and Practise your Persuasive Oral Presentations (must be ready to go in our first class next term)
  • Life of Pi must be fully re-read over the holidays (do NOT simply watch the film!)

Optional:

 

 

Information about the Norm Fary:

Rather than nominating one representative per class, it will be your decision whether you want to enter the Year 11/12 Norm Fary Public Speaking competition. There will be prizes for the best speakers, and the winner will represent our school at ACS Public Speaking. Details can be found here:

 

 

After Dinner Speeches:

 

More are available here:

 

 

 

Practise Language Analysis

 

Practise Articles

Quite a few people could use some more practice at analysing written media texts.

Below you can find some practice articles with general guiding questions.

You can either answer in a question/answer format, or have a go at writing a Language Analysis Essay following the instructions and structure outlined below.

 

 

Language Analysis Essay Overview

Overall Structure:

Advice for writing:

Examples:

 

 

 

 

Persuasive Oral Presentation: Thinking about delivery

 

Even nothing can carry meaning.

A talk is much more than just the words you say. It needs to have variation: moments of light and shade, sections which build and sections which fall, and a shift in tone to match the changing content you are delivering.

Sometimes it can be useful to strip away any meaningful content and look at the importance of delivery in capturing, orientating and guiding an audience. While the following speech in completely meaningless in what is being said, pay close attention to how it is being presented, and note the shifts in the presenter’s tone, volume, pacing and gesture:

.

 

After watching the above speech, consider the following questions:

  • What elements of delivery stood out for you in this performance? Identify as many different techniques as possible.
  • How did the construction of the speech accommodate these elements?
  • How did the nature of the speaker’s delivery change over the course of the speech?

 

 

It’s not enough to question authority. You need to speak with it.

Confidence is the basis of all public speaking. You can have an excellent, logical and factually supported argument, but if you don’t speak with confidence, you will have tremendous difficulty convincing anyone to follow you.

There are many things that we do that make us appear to be lacking in confidence. Our tone, words and stance all pay a crucial part. Learn to control these elements of your delivery, and you will appear confident regardless of how you actually feel.

Watch the below performance by Taylor Mali, and consider: what are the things we do when speaking that make us appear uncertain, uninformed or lacking in conviction?

 

 

After watching the above speech, consider the following questions:

  • How does our tone influence the meaning of our statements?
  • Why is vocal inflection at the end of sentences particularly important?
  • What vocabulary choices convey a disinterested, indecisive or unconvinced tone?
  • Why is it important to speak with conviction, confidence and authority?
  • What choices can you make when writing a speech that will help to achieve this?

 

 

It’s time to write!

You are now at the point when you can begin writing your speech! You should be using all of the lessons learned from the examples you’ve studied and be apply this in what should be the best piece of public speaking that you have ever completed in your life.

Structure is essential to a good speech. Because we can’t re-read your content if we miss something, you need to be clear and purposeful. Don’t forget the basic general structure of a speech that we covered in our first class on this topic:

You will have the opportunity to prepare your speech in detail, so you can play around with this structure and make it a bit less blatant. However, all of these elements should still be included in an order similar to this.

Please keep the following things in mind when writing your speech:

  1. Include persuasive techniques: This is an explicit requirement of the task. You must include a range of persuasive language techniques that we have studied in class. Their usage should be clear and deliberate (i.e. when marking your presentation, I should be able to identify when a technique is used and how it is affecting the audience).
  2. Make it easy on your audience: Having a clear statement of contention, a clear structure and signposting your arguments makes a huge difference to your audience. Remember that we are not reading your speech; we are listening to it, and this means that you need to us a different, clearer and simpler structure than a piece of writing. Return to your message at the end, leave us with a call to action and make it crystal clear what you’ve been arguing and what needs to be done.
  3. Don’t waste your hour in the spotlight: You are asking for roughly five minutes of undivided and very close attention from roughly twenty different people who don’t really know why they should care about what you’re discussing. You need to earn the right to be listened to. Establish your authority, be engaging and speak with conviction. Make us believe in you and what you have to say. Construct a speech with this in mind.

 

 

Learning from others.

It is very useful to look at how other students have approached this task. Examples of this can be found on the Persuasive Oral page. Below are two examples of high scoring oral presentations from previous years. Watch them carefully and consider what elements are done well, and what elements could be improved, as they are also by no means perfect.

 

Topic: Banning ‘the bouncer’ in cricket

Things that are done well in this speech:

  • Good eye contact.
  • Good fluency of delivery.
  • Very good pacing.
  • Good variation of tone.
  • Clear signposting between points.
  • Persuasive techniques are used: emotive language, attacks, alliteration, personal anecdotes, etc.
  • Argument is logical and rebuttal arguments are raised and dealt with.
  • Strong final message.

In your opinion, what could be improved?

 

Topic: We need to go to Mars

Things that are done well in this speech:

  • Interesting hook to begin.
  • Clear outline of topic and contention.
  • Very good eye contact.
  • Very fluent delivery.
  • Good pacing.
  • Very good variation of tone.
  • Persuasive techniques are used: emotive language, colloquial language, expert evidence, listing, inclusive language, repetition, personal anecdote, appeals, etc.
  • Strong final message

What, in your opinion, could be improved?

 

 

Persuasive Techniques Table

 

You can download a copy of the persuasive techniques table we compiled as a class here:

You should use this table to help revise relevant persuasive techniques and use it as a tool to help your write your speeches. Remember that you need to use a range of persuasive techniques (although not necessarily every technique mentioned in this table). Whenever you use a technique, you should actively reflect on what the intended effect on the audience is of using this technique in this way, and whether you are likely to achieve this goal.

Remember that your planning documents are due this Tuesday 23 June. These can be downloaded in the previous blog post.

 

 

Persuasive Oral: Planning, Persuasive Techniques and Examples of Speeches

 

Planning your Speech

You will need to begin planning your speech by filling in the following planning document. The more information and detail you include in your plan, the easier it will be to write your speech. Remember that you also need to be keeping a list of sources that you are using.

This planning sheet is due at the beginning of next week.

You can download the planning document here:

 

 

Using Persuasive Techniques

You must use persuasive techniques in your oral presentation. A number of techniques should be used, and you are seeking to demonstrate your knowledge of each technique by using it correctly and as effectively as possible.

Download and complete the following table. For each of the ten technique you will need to explain what its effect on the audience is when used effectively. For five of the techniques you will need to offer an opinion as to where it would work best in a persuasive speech (i.e. where and how should you use this technique.

This activity is designed to make you engage with the purpose behind using each technique and to consider how you can use it in your own speech before you begin planning and writing your script.

You can download a copy of the ‘Persuasive Techniques: Usage in an Oral Presentation’ table here and complete it in Word:

 

 

Rebuttal Arguments

Generally speaking, a persuasive speech is made up of two types of arguments:

  • Positive Arguments: presenting arguments that support your point of view.
  • Rebuttal Arguments: responding to an opposing side’s argument, explaining why their approach is incorrect or should not be followed and why your side is better.

Most of your speech should be focussed on presenting positive material (i.e. the points/arguments that support your side of the issue). However, you should aim to include one rebuttal argument in your speech, as this shows that you have researched other points of view and have a detailed enough understanding of the topic to successfully explain why they are incorrect.

In general terms, a rebuttal argument should be structured as follows:

  1. Briefly state an opposing argument.
  2. Explain in detail why this argument is incorrect/inaccurate/should be given little weight/etc.
  3. Explain why your position is the correct one/provides a better alternative.

While it isn’t as formal as what you will be producing, the following video provides an good example of a ‘rebuttal’ from the TV show The West Wing. Watch it carefully and consider:

  • What argument is the president responding to?
  • How does he rebut this argument?
  • Can you identify any persuasive techniques that are used to try and sway the audience?

 

 

 

Examples of Persuasive Speeches

Below are some examples of people giving persuasive speeches. Some are included because they are famous, some are included because they particularly effective, some will be by adults and some will be by secondary school students. Keep in mind that these speeches are often on contentious topics – be asking yourself ‘how persuasive are these speakers?’, not ‘do they support my preexisting views on these topics?’.

For each speech you watch, make sure you consider:

  • What is their contention?
  • What arguments do they put forward?
  • What persuasive techniques to they use?
  • What other means do they use to engage and persuade their audience?
  • What made their speech effective/ineffective?

 

Severn Cullis-Suzuki, ‘The Girl who Silenced the World’

 

Stephen Fry: ‘The Catholic Church is not a force for good’

 

Julia Gillard (2012): ‘Misogyny and Sexism Speech’

 

Nelson Mandela: ‘I Am the First Accused’ (speech at trial, 1964)

 

Charlie Chaplin, ‘I Don’t Want to be an Emperor’

 

Emma Watson, ‘Feminism’

 

‘Canadian Seal Hunts’

 

Lulutho Ngcongolo (WIDPSC 2014): ‘Gay Rights in Africa’

 

Kate Garrow (WIDPSC 2014): ‘The Bystander Effect’

 

 

 

Introducing the Persuasive Oral

 

Introducing the Persuasive Oral Presentation

Your task is to prepare a 5 to 7 minute persuasive oral presentation on a current issue that has been discussed in the media. You will need to draw upon the ideas and techniques studied as part of the Language Analysis unit so far and demonstrate your understanding of them through presenting an informative, intelligent and engaging speech.

The notes from our last class can be found here, including the criteria that you will be assessed by.

 

It’s important that you pick an issue that has substance and which you can get passionate about. Have a look at what’s in the media and have a look at the different types of issues and approaches you can take:

 

 

Let’s present a speech…

Your goal is to write and present a speech of at least 3 minutes.You will not have much time to prepare this speech, so you will need to use dot points and use the following structure to ensure your speech has form and purpose.

Have one cue card for each of the following steps. Write our the first sentence for each step/point in full, then use dot-points for everything that follows on that card.

 

Step 1: Open with a hook…

  • This could be an anecdote, interesting fact or rhetorical question…

 

Step 2: Make a statement about your topic and position…

  • Provide a summary of what your three arguments will be…

 

Step 3: State your first argument…

  •  Explain and substantiate your argument…

 

Step 4: State your second argument…

  • Explain and substantiate your argument…

 

Step 5: State your third argument…

  • Explain and substantiate your argument…

 

Step 6: Conclude your argument with a call-to-action…

  • The should be the ‘message’ of your speech…

 

 

Resources that you need to be using

You can now be selecting and researching the topic for your speech, with the aim of starting planning and/or writing your speech early next week. You should make use of the following resources when doing so: